Deadliest Catch Captains Leave Fans Crying With Laughter on Celebrity Family Feud With Their Wild Strip Club Man Cave Guess

The captains of The Deadliest Catch are floundering.

In an exclusive clip of Captains Sig Hansen, Keith Colburn, Jake Anderson, “Wild” Bill Wichrowski, and Johnathan Hillstrand’s upcoming appearance on Celebrity Family Feud, the salty skippers struggle to get answers up on host Steve Harvey’s board to hilarious results.

When Harvey asks Anderson to “name something in a strip club a man might like to have in his man cave,” Anderson replies that the only thing he can think of is “bra” — and when Harvey calls the audience out for their stunned reaction, the captain adds, “I can’t believe underwear didn’t go on there.”

Alas, it doesn’t appear that those polled for the question agreed, as the Deadliest Catch team receives their second big red X. But we do get a peek at previous answers that made it on the board in the top two spots: “6 MVP strippers” and “stripper pole.”

Wichrowski has his mind on other vices, though, and his answer of “the bar” helps the team continue on. Finally, we get to the Time Bandit’s Captain Hillstrand, whose answer leaves everyone on stage in stitches (and the team’s run on this question dead in the water). “Security,” he tells Harvey, who tells him between laughs, “now I love you all even more.”

Sign up for Entertainment Weekly‘s free daily newsletter to get breaking TV news, exclusive first looks, recaps, reviews, interviews with your favorite stars, and more.